WG/Strategies/Anti-Oppression/Minutes/Oct 30 2011: Difference between revisions

From wiki.occupyboston.org
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
Anti-Oppression Working Group


Meeting Notes - October 30, 2011
<p style="text-align: center; ">'''Anti-Oppression Working Group'''</p><p style="text-align: center; ">'''Meeting Notes - October 30, 2011'''</p><p style="text-align: center; ">'''Community Change Inc'''</p>
Agenda
&nbsp;
Check-in (10)
 
-Chose scribe, note taker, time watcher, etc
'''Agenda'''
-Go around: name, oops & ouch moment
 
    Cathy, Michelle, Irene, Carolina, Stecia, Zoe, Nicole, Mezk, Maureen, Chris, Ester, Susie H, Bobyn, Michael M.
'''Check-in (10)'''
*Chose scribe, note taker, time watcher, etc
*Go around: name, oops & ouch moment
Cathy, Michelle, Irene, Carolina, Stacia, Zoe, Nicole, Meck, Maureen, Chris, Ester, Susie H, Bhavin, Michael M.
 
'''Ground rules & discussion (30)'''


Ground rules & discussion (30)
1. Step up, Step back
1. Step up, Step back
    -Facilitators can help w/ this
*Facilitators can help w/ this
    -Its hard work
*Its hard work
 
2. Active listening
2. Active listening
    -Actively engaging with speaker: nodding, affirmative gestures
*Actively engaging with speaker: nodding, affirmative gestures
    -Don’t multi-task while someone else is speaking
*Don’t multi-task while someone else is speaking
    -Possible: not raising hand until someone else is finished speaking
*Possible: not raising hand until someone else is finished speaking
 
3. Allow Space for disagreement
3. Allow Space for disagreement
4. Don’t blame/ shame/ attack
4. Don’t blame/ shame/ attack
5. Speak for yourself, Use I statements
5. Speak for yourself, Use I statements
6. Progressive Stack & Diversity of facilitation techniques
6. Progressive Stack & Diversity of facilitation techniques
    -Have people who self-identify with marginalized groups put higher on the stack
*Have people who self-identify with marginalized groups put higher on the stack
    -EX: people of color, woman, trans, queer, …
*EX: people of color, woman, trans, queer, …
    -ALSO, can put people who have talked a lot lower on stack … Facilitators
*ALSO, can put people who have talked a lot lower on stack … Facilitators
    -Discuss this ahead of time so it is not on facilitator to decide how to manage
*Discuss this ahead of time so it is not on facilitator to decide how to manage


7. Practice ‘both/ and’ thinking not just ‘either/ or’
7. Practice ‘both/ and’ thinking not just ‘either/ or’
    -more than 1 reality exists
*more than 1 reality exists
*EX: should we go to gov. and beg/ ask for stuff or create our own world…&nbsp; actually both are possible
*be mindful of ‘neither/ nor’ possibility
*EX: glass half full, half empty?&nbsp; One could also say: glass is partly full of water and partly full of air


  EX-should we go to gov. and beg/ ask for stuff or create our own world…  actually both are possible
    -be mindful of ‘neither/ nor’ possibility
      EX: glass half full, half empty?  One could also say: glass is partly full of water and partly full of air
 
8. Oops, Ouch, What’s up with that? (& positive hand gestures)
8. Oops, Ouch, What’s up with that? (& positive hand gestures)
    -What’s up with that?: if something may be an ouch, this is an option that asks for clarification and can open up discussion
*What’s up with that?:&nbsp; if something may be an ouch, this is an option that asks for clarification and can open up discussion
 
<span style="color:#2f4f4f;">Create toolbox:</span>
 
*<span style="color:#2f4f4f;">ethics of groundrules</span>
*<span style="color:#2f4f4f;">specific practices and ideas that we have used/ going to use to diversify facilitation techniques</span>
*<span style="color:#2f4f4f;">WHO WOULD LIKE TO WORK ON THIS?</span>
 
<br/><u>Not going to include</u>
1.&nbsp; Assume best intentions
*might not leave room for disscussion
 
&nbsp;


Create toolbox:
'''Working Group Updates (15)'''
-ethics of groundrules
-specific practices and ideas that we have used/ going to use to diversify facilitation techniques
---WHO WOULD LIKE TO WORK ON THIS?


Not going to include
'''Women’s Caucus'''
Assume best intentions
*currently a space for females
    -might not leave room for disscussion
*purpose
*creating a process: discussion about how we are going to decide things
*100 listening; 15-40 in meetings
*being visible at camp & accountable in decision making


Working Group Updates (15)
'''Occupy the Hood'''
Women’s Caucus
*No update on internal discussion
-currently a space for females
*In email: Occupy the Hood would like to ask people to endorse electoral candidates
-purpose
*Questions about relationship between Occupy Boston and Occupy the Hood
-creating a process: discussion about how we are going to decide things
*is it an event or a working group?
-100 listening; 15-40 in meetings
*it looks like it is an ongoing group
-being visible at camp & accountable in decision making
*Centrally controlled group, mainly around Jamal Crawford
*Term has roots in NY (Malcolm X … Center)


Occupy the Hood
'''Anarchist Caucus'''
-No update on internal discussion
*Concern expressed over people always wearing masks…
-In email: Occupy the Hood would like to ask people to endorse electoral candidates
*it is a tactic that may loose its effectiveness
-Questions about relationship between Occupy Boston and Occupy the Hood
*people wearing masks may not identify as anarchists
    -is it an event or a working group?
*hierarchies in media group
    -it looks like it is an ongoing group
*Moving to other spaces
-Centrally controlled group, mainly around Jamal Crawford
*privately owned or foreclosed spaces
-Term has roots in NY (Malcolm X … Center)
*legality of these things


Anarchist Caucus
'''People of Color'''
-Concern expressed over people always wearing masks…
*to ally with Occupy the Hood or not?
    -it is a tactic that may loose its effectiveness
*have had 4 meetings
    -people wearing masks may not identify as anarchists
*working towards statement of purpose
-hierarchies in media group
*homelessness issue
-Moving to other spaces
    -privately owned or foreclosed spaces
    -legality of these things


People of Color
'''Community Organization group'''
-to ally with Occupy the Hood or not?
*Monday meetings in the past
-have had 4 meetings
*Next meeting Tuesday November 1
-working towards statement of purpose
*Purpose of group: possibly moving in direction of becoming more action-oriented
-homelessness issue
Still being discussed


Community Organization group
'''Statements of purpose'''
-Monday meetings in the past
*formed to be the group to work on an Anti-Oppression statement of purpose
-Next meeting Tuesday November 1
*take ‘skeleton’ of ideas they have come up with, and discuss them with other groups.
-Purpose of group: possibly moving in direction of becoming more action-oriented
*have Saturday and Sunday meetings in the future
--Still being discussed
*once Statement of Purpose is completed, the group plans to dissolve


Statements of purpose
'''Transparency Group'''
-formed to be the group to work on an Anti-Oppression statement of purpose
*from emails: having meeting Tuesday (we think)
-take ‘skeleton’ of ideas they have come up with, and discuss them with other groups.
*trying to figure out regular meeting times for groups and possibly posting them somewhere else
-have Saturday and Sunday meetings in the future
-once Statement of Purpose is completed, the group plans to dissolve
Transparency Group
-from emails: having meeting Tuesday (we think)
-trying to figure out regular meeting times for groups and possibly posting them somewhere else


Queer/ Trans Caucus
'''Queer/ Trans Caucus'''
-working on putting up Anti-Oppression signs up around camp
*working on putting up Anti-Oppression signs up around camp
-this group is meeting now… Can anyone fill in?
*this group is meeting now…&nbsp; Can anyone fill in?


Allies against racism, White Allies
'''Allies against racism, White Allies'''
-Question over the existence of group
*Question over the existence of group


Occupy Racism conference call
'''Occupy Racism conference call'''
-anti-racism work at occupations
*anti-racism work at occupations
-messy at most other occupations … but everyone is doing work!
*messy at most other occupations … but everyone is doing work!
-developing email/ resource sharing page
*developing email/ resource sharing page
-wants to stay connected to Anti-Oppression group
*wants to stay connected to Anti-Oppression group


National conference call: Action about Foreclosures
'''National conference call:&nbsp; Action about Foreclosures'''
-Occupy folks and community groups
*Occupy folks and community groups
-Two calls so far
*Two calls so far
-City Life has been on this call
*City Life has been on this call
-Seems that people are using City Life model without talking to City Life first
*Seems that people are using City Life model without talking to City Life first
-Possible Day of Action Nov. 21, 22, 23
*Possible '''Day of Action''' Nov. 21, 22, 23
-national calls about coordinating actions…
*national calls about coordinating actions…
    -possibility of elite group arising that
*possibility of elite group arising that
    -how do people find out about these calls?
*how do people find out about these calls?


'''Youth Group'''
&nbsp;


Youth Group
'''Choosing Direction (30)'''
*4 broad categories of what this group could be ….&nbsp;??
*Network group
*increase transparency of anti-oppression group
*increase visibility of work being done (by many groups) around anti-oppression
*empower '''accountability''' at camp
*offer AO training & facilitation
*offer a safe space
*Coordinate between AO working groups (internal) and reach out to other groups (external)
*what can we '''do '''for anti-oppression now?
*doing actions we think are needed
*posting anti-oppression ground rules on your tent
*there is a Protest-Chaplan group
*are we going to ‘put out fires’ at camp?
*hopes that Safety group does not mirror oppressive ways of this country’s police force
*leadership in dealing with '''urgent issues''' as well as '''developing long term strategy'''... as a group, we want to do both
*we are meeting people and creating relationships throughout this process




'''Message for Reps (20)'''


Choosing Direction (30)
'''Choosing Reps (5)'''
-4 broad categories of what this group could be …. ??
-Network group
-increase transparency of anti-oppression group
-increase visibility of work being done (by many groups) around anti-oppression
-empower accountability at camp
-offer AO training & facilitation
-offer a safe space
-Coordinate between AO working groups (internal) and reach out to other groups (external)
-what can we do for anti-oppression now?
    -doing actions we think are needed
-posting anti-oppression ground rules on your tent
-there is a Protest-Chaplan group
-are we going to ‘put out fires’ at camp?
-hopes that Safety group does not mirror oppressive ways of this country’s police force
-leadership in dealing with urgent issues as well as developing long term strategy... as a group, we want to do both
-we are meeting people and creating relationships throughout this process


Message for Reps (20)
Choosing Reps (5)


Closing Out (10) Go-Round of thoughts
'''Closing Out (10)&nbsp; Go-Round of thoughts'''
-there are real emotions at stake
*there are real emotions at stake
-learning from these meetings and shaping interactions
*learning from these meetings and shaping interactions
-here to contribute b/c I cannot be on the ground that much
*here to contribute b/c I cannot be on the ground that much
-questions about if groups will stay together after this; not feeling excited about doing task-oriented stuff at occupy, but want to work towards it
*questions about if groups will stay together after this;&nbsp; not feeling excited about doing task-oriented stuff at occupy, but want to work towards it
-made a lot of connections, hope to keep them over time
*made a lot of connections, hope to keep them over time
-oil-can with dynamite flying through space… will not last forever in this form
*oil-can with dynamite flying through space…&nbsp; will not last forever in this form
-grateful for this group as a space for reflection; movement moment: need to deal with fast-paced work here
*grateful for this group as a space for reflection; movement moment: need to deal with fast-paced work here
-commitment to this, very involved in on the ground work and it is tiring but I am going to continue
*commitment to this, very involved in on the ground work and it is tiring but I am going to continue
-urgency.. need to not worry about outcomes and just do my work
*urgency.. need to not worry about outcomes and just do my work
-we have won so much already! Claim our victories, reflection time, and take care of each other
*we have won so much already! Claim our victories, reflection time, and take care of each other
-I appreciate that this group exists. ?s over long term strategy
*I appreciate that this group exists.&nbsp;&nbsp;?s over long term strategy
-Learning space, want to contribute
*Learning space, want to contribute
-gentle entry into this movement
*gentle entry into this movement


Next meeting: Saturday 10/5
'''Next meeting: Saturday 10/5'''

Revision as of 04:30, 13 November 2011

Anti-Oppression Working Group

Meeting Notes - October 30, 2011

Community Change Inc

 

Agenda

Check-in (10)

  • Chose scribe, note taker, time watcher, etc
  • Go around: name, oops & ouch moment

Cathy, Michelle, Irene, Carolina, Stacia, Zoe, Nicole, Meck, Maureen, Chris, Ester, Susie H, Bhavin, Michael M.

Ground rules & discussion (30)

1. Step up, Step back

  • Facilitators can help w/ this
  • Its hard work

2. Active listening

  • Actively engaging with speaker: nodding, affirmative gestures
  • Don’t multi-task while someone else is speaking
  • Possible: not raising hand until someone else is finished speaking

3. Allow Space for disagreement

4. Don’t blame/ shame/ attack

5. Speak for yourself, Use I statements

6. Progressive Stack & Diversity of facilitation techniques

  • Have people who self-identify with marginalized groups put higher on the stack
  • EX: people of color, woman, trans, queer, …
  • ALSO, can put people who have talked a lot lower on stack … Facilitators
  • Discuss this ahead of time so it is not on facilitator to decide how to manage

7. Practice ‘both/ and’ thinking not just ‘either/ or’

  • more than 1 reality exists
  • EX: should we go to gov. and beg/ ask for stuff or create our own world…  actually both are possible
  • be mindful of ‘neither/ nor’ possibility
  • EX: glass half full, half empty?  One could also say: glass is partly full of water and partly full of air

8. Oops, Ouch, What’s up with that? (& positive hand gestures)

  • What’s up with that?:  if something may be an ouch, this is an option that asks for clarification and can open up discussion

Create toolbox:

  • ethics of groundrules
  • specific practices and ideas that we have used/ going to use to diversify facilitation techniques
  • WHO WOULD LIKE TO WORK ON THIS?


Not going to include 1.  Assume best intentions

  • might not leave room for disscussion

 

Working Group Updates (15)

Women’s Caucus

  • currently a space for females
  • purpose
  • creating a process: discussion about how we are going to decide things
  • 100 listening; 15-40 in meetings
  • being visible at camp & accountable in decision making

Occupy the Hood

  • No update on internal discussion
  • In email: Occupy the Hood would like to ask people to endorse electoral candidates
  • Questions about relationship between Occupy Boston and Occupy the Hood
  • is it an event or a working group?
  • it looks like it is an ongoing group
  • Centrally controlled group, mainly around Jamal Crawford
  • Term has roots in NY (Malcolm X … Center)

Anarchist Caucus

  • Concern expressed over people always wearing masks…
  • it is a tactic that may loose its effectiveness
  • people wearing masks may not identify as anarchists
  • hierarchies in media group
  • Moving to other spaces
  • privately owned or foreclosed spaces
  • legality of these things

People of Color

  • to ally with Occupy the Hood or not?
  • have had 4 meetings
  • working towards statement of purpose
  • homelessness issue

Community Organization group

  • Monday meetings in the past
  • Next meeting Tuesday November 1
  • Purpose of group: possibly moving in direction of becoming more action-oriented

Still being discussed

Statements of purpose

  • formed to be the group to work on an Anti-Oppression statement of purpose
  • take ‘skeleton’ of ideas they have come up with, and discuss them with other groups.
  • have Saturday and Sunday meetings in the future
  • once Statement of Purpose is completed, the group plans to dissolve

Transparency Group

  • from emails: having meeting Tuesday (we think)
  • trying to figure out regular meeting times for groups and possibly posting them somewhere else

Queer/ Trans Caucus

  • working on putting up Anti-Oppression signs up around camp
  • this group is meeting now…  Can anyone fill in?

Allies against racism, White Allies

  • Question over the existence of group

Occupy Racism conference call

  • anti-racism work at occupations
  • messy at most other occupations … but everyone is doing work!
  • developing email/ resource sharing page
  • wants to stay connected to Anti-Oppression group

National conference call:  Action about Foreclosures

  • Occupy folks and community groups
  • Two calls so far
  • City Life has been on this call
  • Seems that people are using City Life model without talking to City Life first
  • Possible Day of Action Nov. 21, 22, 23
  • national calls about coordinating actions…
  • possibility of elite group arising that
  • how do people find out about these calls?

Youth Group  

Choosing Direction (30)

  • 4 broad categories of what this group could be …. ??
  • Network group
  • increase transparency of anti-oppression group
  • increase visibility of work being done (by many groups) around anti-oppression
  • empower accountability at camp
  • offer AO training & facilitation
  • offer a safe space
  • Coordinate between AO working groups (internal) and reach out to other groups (external)
  • what can we do for anti-oppression now?
  • doing actions we think are needed
  • posting anti-oppression ground rules on your tent
  • there is a Protest-Chaplan group
  • are we going to ‘put out fires’ at camp?
  • hopes that Safety group does not mirror oppressive ways of this country’s police force
  • leadership in dealing with urgent issues as well as developing long term strategy... as a group, we want to do both
  • we are meeting people and creating relationships throughout this process


Message for Reps (20)

Choosing Reps (5)


Closing Out (10)  Go-Round of thoughts

  • there are real emotions at stake
  • learning from these meetings and shaping interactions
  • here to contribute b/c I cannot be on the ground that much
  • questions about if groups will stay together after this;  not feeling excited about doing task-oriented stuff at occupy, but want to work towards it
  • made a lot of connections, hope to keep them over time
  • oil-can with dynamite flying through space…  will not last forever in this form
  • grateful for this group as a space for reflection; movement moment: need to deal with fast-paced work here
  • commitment to this, very involved in on the ground work and it is tiring but I am going to continue
  • urgency.. need to not worry about outcomes and just do my work
  • we have won so much already! Claim our victories, reflection time, and take care of each other
  • I appreciate that this group exists.  ?s over long term strategy
  • Learning space, want to contribute
  • gentle entry into this movement

Next meeting: Saturday 10/5